In my January 2012 Birchbox shipment I received a full size Stila Smudge Stick Water Proof Eyeliner in Peacock {$20}. I LOVE eyeliner. It’s my favorite cosmetic item to try out and I’m always on the look out for the “world’s best eyeliner.” {I haven’t found it yet.}
I do love trying out new eyeliner colors and was thrilled to try out this crazy bright peacock blue color. I definitely liked the color! It was super bright, which I love, although definitely not an everyday eyeliner. I wore it on a day I was wearing all black, so it definitely stood out.
The eyeliner was soft and went on quite easily – almost too easily! I had to remove it and start over on one eye when it went on too thick.
Overall, I have to say I wasn’t thrilled with Stila Smudge Stick Water Proof Eyeliner, mainly because of the claim that it was water proof. My face didn’t get wet and I wasn’t crying, but at the end of the work day I had blue eyeliner running down my face. It was bad. I looked like I’d had myself a good long cry, which was fairly mortifying. I don’t normally have this problem and I wear eyeliner every single day.
I would wear the Stila Smudge Stick Water Proof Eyeliner in Peacock again, but probably only along my top lash line, which is hopefully less likely to run. All told, I’d probably give this product 3 out of 10 stars, and the stars are mostly for the fantastically vibrant color.






























